The ruling affects roughly 20 million Android users in Italy. Meta plans to appeal and has called the fine “disproportionate.” The Garante also weighed a prior 2019 fine against the company and what it assessed as limited cooperation. Its reasoning rests on the ePrivacy Directive as interpreted under Italian law, which treats a smartphone as a private sphere where any access to stored data requires free and informed consent.
One Permission, Many Functions
The problem dates to 2023, when the Facebook app began requesting gallery access through a single, broad permission that covered several functions at once. According to the Garante, the notice shown to users only referred to “other features” and never named the photo suggestion mechanism. The feature was also switched on by default.
Once a user granted that permission, the app had continuous read access to the entire photo library. The regulator said neither users nor the authority itself could verify exactly what was being accessed or used. Meta argued that Ireland should be the competent regulator, but the Garante rejected that. The ePrivacy rules have no “one-stop-shop” mechanism, so national authorities can enforce local law directly.
What Meta Has 60 Days to Change
The fine equals roughly 0.47% of Meta’s global revenue. For scale, Ireland’s DPC fined the company €251 million in December 2024 over a 2018 Facebook security breach. Within 60 days, Meta must rework the feature for Italian users in three ways:
- Obtain separate, explicit consent for the gallery suggestion feature
- Explain clearly what the feature does
- Keep it off by default, including for existing users
The order covers only the on-device photo suggestion feature. It does not address Meta’s AI training data, which the company says is unrelated. A newer cloud-based camera roll feature, launched in the EU and UK in April as an opt-in service for AI-generated collages, is under a separate review by the Italian regulator.
The orders apply to Italy only, but anyone can check their own settings. In the Facebook app, open Settings & privacy and turn off camera roll suggestions. Facebook’s help center says the change applies across all linked devices. For tighter control, Android’s system permissions let you limit or remove the app’s access to photos and videos entirely.
Hashlytics Take
The fine is large, but the more durable point is the mechanism the Garante went after. A single blanket permission that quietly covers a feature users were never told about is a common pattern across mobile apps, and Italy is saying that granting access once does not amount to consenting to every use of it. The jurisdiction ruling matters just as much. Because ePrivacy has no one-stop-shop, a company cannot route every dispute through its preferred lead regulator, which means each EU country can come with its own enforcement. For Meta, the 60-day deadline is a smaller problem than the precedent that a default-on feature built on broad access is now a liability in one of Europe’s largest markets.
Follow Hashlytics on Bluesky, Facebook, LinkedIn , Telegram and X to Get Instant Updates



